Federal judge finds Flint in contempt for failing to replace lead pipes as ordered

In a decision that highlights the ongoing challenges faced by the city of Flint, a federal judge has declared the city in contempt for its failure to comply with a court order mandating the replacement of old lead pipes.

Judge's Finding

U.S. District Judge David Lawson's ruling on Tuesday found Flint in civil contempt after it missed deadlines for pipe-removal outlined in a February 2023 order. The city had previously pledged to complete the pipe replacements by early 2020, but has so far failed to do so.

Legal Action

The contempt ruling followed a June 2023 hearing on a motion filed by the Natural Resources Defense Council, the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan, and Concerned Pastors for Social Action. Judge Lawson, in his decision, emphasized the city's failure to comply with the court's orders and its lack of valid reasons for the delays.

City's Response

The office of Mayor Sheldon Neeley did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the ruling. The Natural Resources Defense Council highlighted that nearly 2,000 homes continue to bear damage from the lead pipe replacement program, including issues with curbs, sidewalks, and lawns.

Consequences and Outlook

Judge Lawson's order did not specify additional penalties for the city's non-compliance, apart from the potential award of attorney fees, costs, and expenses to the plaintiffs. Pastor Allen C. Overton expressed encouragement at the ruling but stressed the importance of completing the lead pipe replacement program and addressing the overdue repairs to residents' properties.

Long-Term Impact

This ruling comes almost a decade after the Flint water crisis began and nearly seven years after a settlement was reached in a citizen lawsuit against the city of Flint and Michigan state officials, signifying the enduring effects of the crisis on the community.