Immigration Blamed for High U.S. Housing Costs Amid Ongoing Affordability Crisis
High housing costs are affecting millions of Americans, driven by a combination of factors including increased demand, construction shortages, and rising rents.
The issue of housing affordability has become a pressing concern for many Americans, as soaring home prices and rising rents continue to strain household budgets. In a recent vice presidential debate,
Senator JD Vance pointed to immigration as a major factor contributing to the affordability crisis, asserting that the influx of illegal immigrants has intensified competition for limited housing resources.
Vance's Claims
During the debate, Vance referenced a Federal Reserve study, claiming it established a direct link between increased levels of migration, particularly illegal immigration, and rising housing prices. However, the study referred to by Vance was not a comprehensive analysis but rather a prepared speech by a Federal Reserve official, suggesting a connection without providing conclusive evidence.
Economists specializing in the real estate market have highlighted various structural factors as primary drivers of escalating housing costs, including a significant decline in new construction following the 2007-09 Great Recession, leading to a pronounced housing shortage. While the role of immigration in influencing real estate prices is not as straightforward, it is evident that home prices have surged approximately 53% since January 2020, prior to the onset of the pandemic, pricing many potential homebuyers out of the market. Simultaneously, rents have increased by around 25% in the same timeframe, categorizing half of all renters as 'cost burdened'—a record high percentage of renters now allocating over 30% of their income on housing expenses, as reported by the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies.
Nationwide Affordability Crisis
The affordability crisis is no longer confined to major urban centers; it has permeated communities across the country, affecting individuals and families in both metropolitan and rural areas alike. Shamus Roller, executive director of the National Housing Law Project, emphasized that the crisis is contributing to widespread economic anxiety nationwide, signaling a broader economic impact.
Share news