Lawyer Questions Credibility of Abuse Allegations at New Hampshire Youth Detention Center Trial
Lawyer defending NH youth detention center alleges plaintiff's past troubles discredit abuse claims, while the state challenges Meehan's credibility in civil trial.
The trial of the lawsuit filed against the state of New Hampshire by David Meehan has attracted attention due to the serious abuse allegations at its youth detention center. The trial has revealed intense cross-examinations and efforts to challenge Meehan's credibility. The case has broader implications, given the significant number of former residents who have filed lawsuits against the state for negligence that allowed abuse to persist over six decades.
On Monday, Martha Gaythwaite, representing the state of New Hampshire, launched a vigorous attack on Meehan's credibility, portraying him as a troubled teen who now seeks unwarranted compensation as an adult. She questioned his account of the abuse and highlighted his troubled past, suggesting that he was appropriately disciplined for his actions as a youth.
Unusual Dynamic in the Legal Battle
The legal battle has an unusual dynamic, with the attorney general's office prosecuting former workers while also defending the state against civil lawsuits. This dynamic has led to a dual role for the state lawyers, who are simultaneously relying on Meehan's testimony in criminal trials while attempting to undermine his credibility in the civil trial.
Gaythwaite raised doubts about Meehan's account of contracting gonorrhea from a rape incident, pointing to conflicting evidence about his medical treatment after returning from a furlough. Additionally, she questioned his assertion of a violent rape, presenting log books that described a different cause for his injuries.
Focus on Mental Health History
Throughout the cross-examination, Meehan faced questions about his mental health history, including incidents that the defense sought to link to the timing of his lawsuit. The defense argues that Meehan's delayed legal action should absolve the state of liability, citing the statute of limitations for such lawsuits.
Meehan's emotional response in court underscored the toll of having to recount the abuse he alleges experiencing at the youth detention center. His outburst expressed his frustration at being portrayed as undeserving of justice due to his troubled past.
Share news