2025 NFL Draft: Overrated and Underrated Prospects to Watch Ahead of the Big Event

As the countdown to the 2025 NFL Draft continues, the spotlight on various prospects is intensifying. With only a week left until the highly anticipated event, discussions surrounding the potential picks are reaching a fever pitch. While some players are gaining traction based on their impressive measurables and potential, others with proven abilities are at risk of being overlooked. In this article, we delve into the prospects who are generating buzz, shedding light on those who may be overvalued and those who deserve more recognition.

Overrated Prospects

Tetairoa McMillan, a wide receiver from the University of Arizona, has garnered significant attention in the lead-up to the draft. Standing at an impressive 6-foot-5, McMillan possesses an elite frame and catch radius, capable of making difficult catches look effortless. His fluidity, strong hands, and willingness to work across the middle further enhance his appeal. However, after observing his performance against a struggling TCU secondary in 2024, concerns regarding his top-end speed and ability to consistently separate from skilled corners have emerged. While he remains a first-round prospect, it is believed that his true value lies in the mid-20s range.

Another prospect generating buzz is Nic Scourton, an edge rusher from Texas A&M. With a combination of tools and a strong motor, Scourton has showcased versatility as a situational inside rusher. However, he is considered a work in progress and not yet ready for the demands of the first round. Scourton primarily relies on a spin move and can exploit tackles lacking a solid punch, but there are calls for him to develop a long-arm power move to diversify his skill set. While he possesses high potential at a premium position, expectations for immediate impact may be premature.

Mykel Williams, an edge rusher from the University of Georgia, has drawn attention as a traits-based projection, often mocked as a top-15 pick. However, the production does not align with the hype. With only five sacks in the previous season, one coming from a true one-on-one win against an offensive lineman, Williams has recorded a mere 14 sacks in 773 pass-rushing snaps across three seasons. While he exhibits twitchiness, length, and some bend, the need for further development raises questions about his immediate impact as a rookie.