
Philadelphia Man Won't be Retried in 2011 Shooting Case After Decade in Prison
Philadelphia man, C.J. Rice, released after flawed trial and 10 years in prison for 2011 shooting. Case dismissed. Surgeon's testimony pivotal.

A Philadelphia man, C.J. Rice, has been released from prison after spending over a decade behind bars for a 2011 shooting that injured four people, including a 6-year-old girl. Rice, who was 17 years old at the time of the incident, has been declared not guilty and will not face a retrial, following a federal judge's decision and the announcement by District Attorney Larry Krasner on Monday.
Legal Closure
This legal closure comes after the case against Rice has been formally dismissed, and this decision marks the end of a long legal battle that saw Rice serving a 30- to 60-year prison term until his release following the federal court ruling late last year.
New Examination of Evidence
District Attorney Krasner emphasized that while most of the exonerations his office has championed were clearcut cases of innocence, Rice's case was more nuanced, falling within the 15% of cases considered "murky" by the office. This new outlook at the evidence led to the decision not to retry the case.
Key Points in the Reversal
The reversal in Rice's case was based on critical points, including the testimony of a surgeon who asserted that Rice could not have been the person seen fleeing the scene due to serious injuries sustained in a separate shooting just three weeks earlier. Additionally, the revelation that the evidence of Rice's guilt was weak, with only one of the four victims being able to identify him, further contributed to the decision.
Questionable Legal Procedures
Rice's legal team, during a news conference, highlighted the flaws in the case, pointing to issues of faulty eyewitness identification, ineffective counsel, and overreach by prosecutors. The legal director of the Pennsylvania Innocence Project emphasized that the crime should have been thoroughly investigated before the trial, rather than years later.
Impact of Wrongful Conviction
Commenting on the wrongful conviction, the legal director of the Pennsylvania Innocence Project stressed the irreparable impact, stating that although Rice has been released, over a decade of his life had been lost to wrongful conviction, and this cannot be restored.
This case sheds light on the complexities and challenges within the legal system, urging for a thorough review of evidence and procedures to prevent such miscarriages of justice in the future.
Share news