Cody Rhodes and WWE Face Lawsuit Over American Nightmare Trademark Dispute

In a legal turn of events, Cody Rhodes, WWE, and Fanatics are facing a lawsuit over the trademark dispute of the term "American Nightmare." The plaintiff, Wesley Eisold, the lead singer of the band American Nightmare, has taken the matter to federal court in California.

Background of the Trademark Dispute

The trademark dispute connects to the formation of the American Nightmare band by Wesley Eisold in 1998. The band recently toured in 2022. Additionally, Eisold registered the "American Nightmare" trademark in 2016 for use in music, clothing, and entertainment services. Interestingly, Cody Rhodes also adopted the "American Nightmare" moniker in 2016, leading to questions about the overlap and potential infringement between the two parties.

In response to this trademark conflict, Cody Rhodes sought to trademark the term in March 2019. However, Wesley Eisold opposed the application, resulting in a complex legal battle. After two years of negotiations, both parties reached a settlement in March 2021. This allowed Rhodes to secure the trademark under specific terms for its use on merchandise.

Allegations of Settlement Violation and Legal Proceedings

Wesley Eisold is now alleging that the terms of the settlement have been violated, prompting him to file the lawsuit. In response, Rhodes, WWE, and Fanatics have addressed the legal challenge. The outcome of these proceedings will likely hinge on the interpretation of the settlement terms and the extent of their implementation by the parties involved.

The legal dispute has sparked a range of reactions from both the public and industry insiders. The wrestling and music communities are closely observing the developments in this case, with a mix of opinions on the actions of both parties. Some are questioning the validity of Eisold's claims, while others express support for his position as the original creator of the "American Nightmare" concept in the music arena.